Home / Blog / Coney Island Chronicles: Brooklyn’s Hidden Art and History

Colorful amusement rides at Coney Island with the iconic Wonder Wheel in the background.

Coney Island Chronicles: Brooklyn’s Hidden Art and History

Coney Island pulses with energy, a place where history, art, and quirky charm collide. Beyond the flashing lights of amusement rides and the salty breeze of the boardwalk, you’ll find a treasure trove of Brooklyn’s hidden art, historical gems, and offbeat attractions.

This guide digs into the lesser-known stories, street art, and cultural landmarks that make Coney Island a must-visit for summer adventurers seeking a unique Brooklyn tour guide experience. Get ready to see this iconic destination through a fresh lens, packed with local tales and hidden spots that reveal the heart of Brooklyn’s seaside playground.

Experience Coney Island’s Electric PastConey Island Nostalgia

Coney Island’s Historical Roots: A Playground with a Past

Coney Island started as a quiet stretch of sand, home to the Lenape people who called it Narrioch. By the 1820s, it transformed into a getaway for New Yorkers craving escape. The first hotel popped up in 1829, drawing wealthy visitors by carriage. By the late 1800s, the area exploded into a national sensation, with amusement parks, hotels, and bathhouses catering to millions. Steeplechase Park, Dreamland, and Luna Park defined the early 20th century, each competing to dazzle visitors with wild rides and spectacles. Steeplechase boasted a mechanical horse race and a massive ballroom, while Luna Park lit up the night with colorful lights and a circus featuring camels and elephants. Dreamland, with its sterile white buildings, offered a refined vibe, complete with a Japanese tea pavilion and a dramatic “Hellgate” ride simulating tenement fires.

The 1870s saw the arrival of Charles I. D. Looff, a Danish woodcarver who crafted the first carousel at Coney Island in 1876. His hand-carved designs set the stage for the area’s artistic legacy. By the early 1900s, the boardwalk buzzed with activity, hosting everything from boxing matches to beauty contests. The Coney Island Athletic Club, opened in 1897, even hosted the first filmed heavyweight fight in 1899 between James J. Jeffries and Tom Sharkey. These historical layers make Coney Island one of the top Brooklyn historical sites, where every corner whispers stories of a bygone era.

Brooklyn’s Revolutionary War RootsBrooklyn Walking Tour

Coney Island Museum: A Peek into the Past

Front facade of the Coney Island Museum with vintage signage and murals.

Tucked at 1208 Surf Avenue, the Coney Island Museum stands as a love letter to the area’s storied past. This small but mighty museum, run by the nonprofit Coney Island USA, showcases artifacts, photos, and exhibits that bring the People’s Playground to life. You’ll find relics from the glory days of Steeplechase, Luna Park, and Dreamland, including vintage bumper cars and funhouse mirrors. One gem is the collection of James “Jimmy” Onorato’s diaries, the longtime manager of Steeplechase Park, offering a firsthand glimpse into the park’s operations and the characters who shaped it.

The museum also highlights quirky moments, like the 1905 exhibition of 51 Igorrotes from the Philippines at Luna Park, a spectacle that drew crowds but sparked debate. Admission is budget-friendly, and the exhibits rotate, so you’ll always find something fresh. It’s a perfect stop for history buffs seeking hidden gems in Brooklyn that capture Coney Island’s eclectic spirit.

TownePlace Suites by Marriott New York BrooklynBrooklyn Adventure

Coney Art Walls: A Street Art Haven

A street art mural at the Coney Art Walls outdoor gallery.

For art lovers, Coney Art Walls is a must-see. Launched in 2015 by Thor Equities and curated by Jeffrey Deitch, this outdoor museum between West 15th Street and Stillwell Avenue transforms blank walls into a vibrant gallery of Brooklyn street art. Over 30 artists from around the world contribute murals each summer, creating a rotating showcase that blends gritty urban vibes with Coney Island’s playful aesthetic. You’ll spot works by heavyweights like Crash, Daze, Lady Pink, Futura, Shepard Fairey, Nychos, D*Face, Buff Monster, among others. These are set against the backdrop of the iconic Parachute Jump and roller coasters.

The Dreamland Artist Club, led by Steve Powers, added hand-painted signs to rides and arcades, preserving the tradition of Coney Island’s bold, carnival-style art. The walls change yearly, so every visit feels new. Pair your trip with a stop at Smorgasburg’s food vendors for a full day of art and flavor. This spot is a standout for Brooklyn offbeat attractions, offering a free, open-air experience that’s as colorful as the boardwalk itself.

Brooklyn’s Street Art CultureBrooklyn Graffiti Workshop

Eldorado Auto Skooter: Bumper Cars with a Cultural Twist

The Eldorado Auto Skooter, a beloved Coney Island staple since 1973, isn’t just a bumper car ride—it’s a cultural landmark. Located on Surf Avenue, this spot doubles as an arcade and a filming location for the TV series Mr. Robot, where it served as the secret HQ for fsociety. Local artist Steve Powers designed the “Bump Your Ass Off” signs, adding a cheeky nod to Brooklyn street art. The speakers blasting music here trace their roots to Studio 54’s disco era, giving the ride a retro edge.

This attraction is a hidden gem for adults seeking thrills beyond the typical rides. The bumper cars, paired with DJ beats and vibrant signage, make it one of the best things to do in Coney Island for a dose of nostalgia and fun. Don’t miss the New Year’s Eve parties, a local tradition that keeps the energy high even in winter.

The Coney Island History Project: Stories from the Boardwalk

For a deeper look into Coney Island’s soul, visit the Coney Island History Project. This free exhibit, located under the Wonder Wheel, offers a trove of oral histories, photos, and artifacts. You can listen to tales from locals like those who grew up on West 33rd Street, where the Jefferson Baths once stood, a bathhouse and summer resort from 1910. The project also runs walking tours, led by guides like Michael, who share insider stories about landmarks like Norton’s Point trolley ramp, demolished in 1948, or the Atlantis bar, now Cha-Cha’s nightclub.

These tours are a goldmine for anyone craving Brooklyn sightseeing tours that go beyond the surface. They reveal the lives of everyday people—immigrants, workers, and dreamers—who shaped Coney Island. Check the schedule at the Coney Island History Project website and book a spot for a walk through history.

Hidden Gems In All Five BoroughsBoroughs of NYC Tour

The Parachute Jump: An Artistic Icon

The Parachute Jump tower against a clear blue sky.

The Parachute Jump, a 262-foot steel tower, looms over Coney Island like a sentinel. Built for the 1939 New York World’s Fair, it moved to Steeplechase Park in 1941 and became a beloved landmark. Though it stopped operating as a ride in 1964, its skeletal frame now serves as a canvas for light displays and a backdrop for Brooklyn street art. A 1947 photo, Modern Venus of 1947, captures a beauty contest winner posing atop the Jump, channeling Hollywood glamour.

Today, the Jump is a designated landmark, its silhouette a symbol of Coney Island’s enduring allure. Snap a photo at sunset when its lights glow, and you’ll see why it’s one of the top Brooklyn historical sites. It’s a quick stop but a powerful reminder of the area’s blend of history and art.

360-Degree Views Of The CityOne World Observatory

Totonno’s Pizzeria: A Culinary Landmark

No visit to Coney Island is complete without a slice at Totonno’s Pizzeria, a hidden gem in Brooklyn since 1924. Founded by Antonio Pero, a former Lombardi’s employee, this coal-fired oven pizzeria on Neptune Avenue serves pies made the same way for nearly a century. Featured on shows like Ugly Delicious and Somebody Feed Phil, Totonno’s is a pilgrimage site for pizza lovers. The simple menu—classic Margherita or white pie—lets the crispy, smoky crust shine.

The pizzeria’s weathered storefront and no-frills vibe add to its charm, making it a perfect stop for foodies seeking Brooklyn’s offbeat attractions. Grab a pie, sit at a checkered tablecloth, and soak in the history of one of America’s oldest pizzerias.

NYC Brooklyn Bridge and DUMBO Food TourTaste Your Way

The New York Aquarium: A Hidden Gem with History

The New York Aquarium, the oldest in the U.S., sits on the Riegelmann Boardwalk and offers more than just marine life. Opened in 1896 at Battery Park before moving to Coney Island in 1957, it’s a cornerstone of Brooklyn’s historical sites. The Ocean Wonders: Sharks! exhibit lets you walk through a tunnel surrounded by sharks, rays, and sea turtles, while the Canyon’s Edge tank brings you face-to-face with sandbar sharks. The sea lion shows steal the spotlight, with acrobatic performances that delight all ages.

This aquarium is a hidden gem in Brooklyn, blending education with entertainment. It’s open year-round, and the outdoor touch pools are a hit for kids. Plan a visit to see why it’s a top pick for things to do in Coney Island.

Coney Island Circus Sideshow: A Quirky Tradition

A circus performer balancing on a tall unicycle.

For a taste of old-school Coney Island, catch a show at the Coney Island Circus Sideshow, run by Coney Island USA. This quirky attraction keeps the spirit of the 19th-century freak shows alive with fire-eaters, sword-swallowers, and contortionists. Performers bring a modern twist to the classic sideshow, with acts like the J.A.W.S. Jiggle and Wiggle Spectacular celebrating the 50th anniversary of Jaws.

Tickets are affordable, and shows run multiple times daily from June to July. It’s one of the most unique offbeat attractions in Brooklyn, perfect for those who love a bit of weird with their history. Check the schedule at coneyisland.com for showtimes.

The Ford Amphitheater: Architecture Meets Art

The Ford Amphitheater on the Riegelmann Boardwalk is a visual stunner. Built in 1923 as part of the Childs Restaurant chain, this Spanish Colonial-style building boasts nautical-themed details and intricate tilework. Once a dining spot, it now hosts concerts and events, with a rooftop lounge offering views of the boardwalk and ocean. Its designation as a historic landmark makes it a must-see for architecture fans.

The amphitheater’s blend of history and modern entertainment makes it a standout among Brooklyn historical sites. Stop by for a show or just admire the facade—it’s a quick but rewarding addition to your Coney Island adventure.

Brooklyn Bridge Photography TourBrooklyn’s Architectural Charm

Brooklyn Cyclones at MCU Park: Baseball by the Beach

Catch a game at MCU Park, home of the Brooklyn Cyclones, a minor-league team affiliated with the New York Mets. This ballpark, steps from the boardwalk, offers affordable tickets starting at $20 and a unique oceanfront view. Games run from April to September, often ending with fireworks that light up the beach. The Cyclones embody Coney Island’s community spirit.

A game here is a family-friendly way to experience things to do in Coney Island. Grab a hot dog, cheer for the home team, and soak in the laid-back vibe of this hidden gem in Brooklyn.

The Mermaid Parade: A Celebration of Art and Eccentricity

Parade participants in mermaid costumes marching during Coney Island’s Mermaid Parade.

Each June, Coney Island transforms into a glittering undersea fantasy for one of New York City’s most beloved and eccentric events: the Mermaid Parade. Launched in 1983 by the nonprofit Coney Island USA, the parade was created as a way to celebrate the neighborhood’s quirky, creative spirit and to usher in the summer season with flair. Inspired by the wild, theatrical Mardi Gras-style processions that once defined Coney Island in the early 1900s, the Mermaid Parade is now the largest art parade in the U.S., drawing tens of thousands of participants and spectators each year.

What sets the Mermaid Parade apart is its celebration of individual expression and artistry. Locals, artists, performers, and out-of-towners spend weeks crafting elaborate sea creature costumes, mermaid tails, tridents, pirate gear, and aquatic-themed floats. The result is a moving spectacle of glitter, shells, wigs, paint, and wild imagination. You’ll see everything from neon jellyfish stilt walkers to families dressed as undersea kingdoms, all marching to the sound of live brass bands, DJs, and drums.

Former parade royalty has included figures like Lou Reed, Debbie Harry, and Amanda Palmer, adding a touch of celebrity to the celebration while keeping it rooted in Brooklyn’s offbeat, grassroots culture.

More than just a fun day out, the Mermaid Parade is a living tribute to Coney Island’s past, celebrating its legacy of performance art, inclusivity, and carnival history. If you’re looking for one of the most vibrant, offbeat attractions in Brooklyn, the Mermaid Parade is it. Bring a camera, wear something outrageous, and immerse yourself in a celebration where art, history, and community come together in the most playful way possible. From the boardwalk to the beach, it’s a day of pure Coney Island magic you won’t forget.

Coney Island’s Bold Boardwalk SpiritThe Lion King

Hidden Tales of Coney Island: Local Legends

Coney Island’s history brims with local stories. Take the Jefferson Baths, a 1910 bathhouse on West 33rd Street, where families like Gerard’s rented lockers in the 1970s. Or the Atlantis bar, a 1950s hotspot now reborn as Cha-Cha’s. Then there’s the tale of Alessandro Barboni, who ran a restaurant in the 1930s, possibly tied to Guffanti’s Inn, a forgotten eatery on Surf Avenue. These stories, preserved by the Coney Island History Project, paint a vivid picture of a community shaped by immigrants and dreamers.

Planning Your Coney Island Adventure

Coney Island is a summer must, with its blend of Brooklyn’s hidden art, history, and quirky charm. Start at the Coney Island Museum for a historical overview, then hit the Coney Art Walls for vibrant murals. Ride the Eldorado Bumper Cars, catch a Cyclones game, or join The Mermaid Parade. Don’t skip Totonno’s for a slice or the aquarium for marine wonders. The Mermaid Parade and Circus Sideshow add a dose of eccentricity, while the Parachute Jump and Ford Amphitheater offer iconic backdrops.

For a seamless trip, check out Brooklyn sightseeing tours or plan your day with a Brooklyn tour guide. Most spots are budget-friendly, with free access to the boardwalk, beach, and Coney Art Walls. The museum and sideshow charge small fees, but they’re worth every penny. Pack sunscreen, comfortable shoes, and a camera to capture the magic.

Graffiti & Street Art Walking TourSoul of Bushwick

VisitNYC.com: Your Coney Island Travel Look-In

A panoramic view of the Coney Island boardwalk

Coney Island is more than an amusement park—it’s a living canvas of Brooklyn’s hidden art, historical sites, and offbeat attractions. From the Coney Art Walls to the History Project’s tales, every corner reveals a story. Whether you’re chasing things to do in Coney Island or seeking a Brooklyn tour guide, this seaside gem delivers.

Let VisitNYC.com, your go-to for a New York City travel guide, help you plan a trip packed with hidden gems in Brooklyn and beyond. Contact VisitNYC.com today to craft your perfect Coney Island adventure!

Explore NYC beyond BrooklynNew York CityPASS®