If you’re looking for a place in New York City that feels like a living piece of history, McSorley’s Old Ale House is it. Located at 15 East 7th Street in Manhattan’s East Village, this iconic pub is the oldest bar in NYC, pouring drinks since 1854. With its sawdust-covered floors, cash-only policy, and walls plastered with memorabilia, McSorley’s NYC offers a raw, unfiltered glimpse into the city’s past.
From its gangster past to its role in a landmark 1970 court case, this bar is more than just a place to grab a beer—it’s a time capsule. In this detailed guide, you’ll learn about McSorley’s NYC history, its unique character, and how to enjoy it alongside other historic pubs in New York City. Plus, we’ll share tips for a local-led tour to discover more of NYC’s storied haunts.
The Beginnings of McSorley’s: A Pub Born in 1854
McSorley’s Old Ale House opened its doors in 1854, founded by John McSorley, an Irish immigrant who settled in New York City. At the time, the East Village was a bustling neighborhood filled with Irish and German immigrants, and McSorley’s quickly became a gathering spot for locals. The bar’s original name, “The Old House at Home,” reflected its welcoming vibe, offering a place for workers, families, and friends to share a drink and a story. John McSorley built the pub with his own hands, using wood from old ships for the bar and tables, giving it a rugged, nautical feel that still lingers today.
The pub’s early years were marked by its simplicity. It served only two drinks: light ale and dark ale, both brewed on-site in small batches. The menu was basic—think cheese, crackers, and onions—served on wooden boards. The sawdust on the floor absorbed spills, and the potbelly stove in the corner kept the place warm. John’s philosophy was to keep things straightforward, a tradition that’s endured for over 160 years. By the late 19th century, McSorley’s NYC was a neighborhood staple, drawing everyone from dockworkers to politicians.
The bar’s location at 15 East 7th Street placed it in the heart of a vibrant community. The East Village was a melting pot, and McSorley’s Old Ale House reflected that diversity. Irish immigrants shared tables with German brewers, and the pub’s communal atmosphere fostered a sense of belonging. John McSorley himself was a fixture, often behind the bar, chatting with patrons and ensuring the ale kept flowing. His commitment to quality and community laid the foundation for McSorley’s NYC history as a place where stories are born.
The Gangster Era: McSorley’s and the Underworld
By the early 20th century, McSorley’s NYC had earned a reputation as a hangout for some of New York City’s shadier characters. During Prohibition (1920–1933), when alcohol was banned across the U.S., McSorley’s Old Ale House didn’t miss a beat. The bar operated as a speakeasy, serving its famous ales in secret to loyal patrons. Its gangster past came alive during this time, as mobsters and bootleggers frequented the pub, drawn by its discreet location and loyal clientele. The sawdust floors and dimly lit rooms provided the perfect cover for shady deals.
One notable figure rumored to have visited was Tammany Hall boss William “Big Bill” Dwyer, a notorious bootlegger who controlled much of NYC’s illegal liquor trade. While no hard evidence ties Dwyer directly to McSorley’s, the bar’s reputation as a mob-friendly spot made it a likely haunt for his crew. The bartenders, known for their tight-lipped nature, never ratted out their patrons, earning McSorley’s NYC a place in the city’s underworld lore. Patrons would enter through a side door, whisper a password, and sip ale in the back room, far from prying eyes.
The gangster past added to McSorley’s gritty charm. The bar’s walls, covered in old photos, newspaper clippings, and artifacts, tell stories of this era. A pair of handcuffs, said to have belonged to Harry Houdini, hangs behind the bar, hinting at the colorful characters who passed through. The pub’s cash-only policy, still in place today, likely started during Prohibition to avoid paper trails. This rough-around-the-edges vibe made McSorley’s Old Ale House a place where history felt alive, not polished or staged.
The 1970 Court Case: A Turning Point for McSorley’s
McSorley’s Old Ale House made headlines in 1970 due to a landmark legal battle, known as the McSorley’s Old Ale House 1970 court case. For over a century, the bar had a strict men-only policy, a tradition rooted in its early days as a working-class pub. Women were not allowed to enter, a rule enforced with a gruff “Sorry, no ladies.” This changed when two women, Barbara Shaum and Faith Seidenberg, challenged the policy, arguing it violated anti-discrimination laws.
The case, Seidenberg v. McSorley’s Old Ale House, went to federal court, and in August 1970, a judge ruled in favor of the plaintiffs. McSorley’s NYC was ordered to admit women, marking a significant shift in the bar’s history. The first women entered on August 10, 1970, and while some regulars grumbled, the change brought McSorley’s into the modern era. Today, the bar welcomes everyone, and the court case is a point of pride, showing how McSorley’s Old Ale House adapted to changing times while keeping its core identity.
The case also highlighted McSorley’s role as a cultural touchstone. The national media covered the story, and the bar became a symbol of both tradition and progress. The walls, still lined with artifacts from the era, include newspaper clippings about the case, reminding visitors of its impact. The McSorley’s Old Ale House 1970 court case is a testament to how even the oldest bar in NYC can evolve while staying true to its roots.
The McSorley’s Experience: What Makes It Unique
Walking into McSorley’s Old Ale House today feels like stepping into 1854. The sawdust on the floor crunches under your feet, and the walls are covered with memorabilia—old photos, vintage signs, and even wishbones left by soldiers heading to World War I. The bar only serves two drinks: light ale and dark ale, served in pairs of small mugs for about $7. The cash-only policy adds to the old-school vibe, so don’t expect to pay with a card. The bartenders, often gruff but friendly, keep the atmosphere lively, shouting “Two and two!” as they deliver your ales.
The menu is as simple as it was in John McSorley’s day. You can order a cheese plate with cheddar, crackers, and raw onions, or the famous “McSorley’s burger,” a juicy patty served with fries. The food is hearty and pairs perfectly with the ale, which is brewed to the same recipe used since the 19th century. The bar’s communal tables encourage conversation, and you’ll likely share a bench with strangers who become friends by the end of the night.
McSorley’s NYC is also known for its characters. Regulars, some who’ve been coming for decades, swap stories with tourists and locals alike. The bar’s cats, a tradition since the early days, roam freely, adding to the quirky charm. The potbelly stove still warms the room in winter, and the lack of modern amenities like TVs keeps the focus on conversation. This raw, unpretentious vibe makes McSorley’s Old Ale House a must-visit for anyone seeking the heart of NYC.
Notable Visitors and Cultural Impact
McSorley’s Old Ale House has welcomed a who’s-who of notable figures over the years. Presidents like Abraham Lincoln and Theodore Roosevelt reportedly stopped by, as did writers like E.E. Cummings and John Lennon. The bar’s literary connections are strong—poet Dylan Thomas was a regular, and his visits inspired poems and stories. The walls display photos and letters from famous patrons, making McSorley’s NYC a living museum of cultural history.
The bar has also appeared in films, TV shows, and books, cementing its status as a cultural icon. In The Godfather Part II, a young Vito Corleone is seen drinking at a bar resembling McSorley’s, capturing its gangster past. The TV show How I Met Your Mother featured a bar inspired by McSorley’s, with sawdust floors and communal tables. These appearances have made McSorley’s Old Ale House a pilgrimage site for fans of NYC’s gritty, authentic side.
The bar’s cultural impact extends to its role in NYC’s Irish community. As one of the city’s oldest Irish pubs, it’s a hub for St. Patrick’s Day celebrations, with lines stretching around the block. The sense of history and community makes McSorley’s NYC a place where you feel connected to the city’s past, whether you’re a first-time visitor or a lifelong New Yorker.
The Bar’s Enduring Traditions
McSorley’s Old Ale House is a place of traditions that have barely changed since 1854. The cash-only policy is one of the most famous, requiring you to bring bills or hit an ATM before your visit. The two-ale system—light and dark, served in pairs—has been a staple since the beginning. The bartenders, many of whom have worked there for decades, follow a strict code: serve fast, keep it friendly, and don’t mess with the vibe.
The wishbones above the bar are another tradition. During World War I, soldiers hung wishbones for good luck before heading overseas. Those who returned broke theirs, but many remain, a haunting reminder of those who didn’t. The bar’s cats, named after Irish figures like Seamus, are a nod to the pub’s roots, keeping mice at bay and charming patrons. Even the sawdust, swept daily but never fully removed, is a tradition that ties McSorley’s NYC to its working-class origins.
These traditions make McSorley’s Old Ale House feel timeless. You won’t find craft cocktails or trendy decor here—just ale, history, and conversation. The bar’s refusal to modernize is part of its charm, drawing visitors who want an authentic experience in a city that’s always changing.
McSorley’s in the Modern Era: Staying True to Its Roots
Today, McSorley’s Old Ale House remains a beloved spot in Manhattan’s East Village. The bar is still family-owned, with the Maher family taking over in the 20th century and preserving its traditions. Despite its fame, McSorley’s NYC hasn’t lost its gritty charm. The bar doesn’t take reservations, so you might wait in line on busy nights, but the experience is worth it. The crowd is a mix of tourists, locals, and college students from nearby NYU, all drawn to the bar’s unique vibe.
The bar’s location in the McSorley’s Old Ale House location makes it easy to reach, just a short walk from Union Square. It’s open daily from 11 a.m. to 1 a.m., and the cash-only policy means you’ll need about $20-$30 for a round of ales and food. The bar’s website, a rare nod to modernity, lists its history and menu, but the real draw is the in-person experience. McSorley’s NYC is a place where you feel the weight of history in every mug of ale.
The bar has also embraced its role as a tourist attraction while staying true to its roots. Visitors come from around the world to sip ale and take photos of the memorabilia-covered walls. Yet, McSorley’s Old Ale House remains a local spot, with regulars who treat it like a second home. This balance of old and new makes it a standout among historic pubs in New York City.
Tips for Visiting McSorley’s Old Ale House
Planning a visit to McSorley’s Old Ale House? Here are some tips to make the most of your experience. First, bring cash—McSorley’s NYC doesn’t accept cards, and the nearest ATM is a block away. Expect to spend $15-$30 for drinks and food. The bar gets crowded, especially on weekends and St. Patrick’s Day, so arrive early (around 11 a.m.) to avoid lines. If you’re with a group, be prepared to split up, as tables are communal and space is tight.
Dress casually—jeans and a sweater fit the bar’s laid-back vibe. The sawdust floors and old wooden tables aren’t kind to fancy shoes, so keep it practical. Try both the light and dark ales; they’re served in pairs, and each has a distinct flavor. The cheese plate is a classic choice, but the burger is a hearty option if you’re hungry. Don’t expect a quiet night—McSorley’s Old Ale House is loud, lively, and full of energy.
The bar is at McSorley’s Old Ale House location (15 East 7th Street), a short walk from the Astor Place subway station (6 train) or Union Square (4, 5, 6, L, N, Q, R, W trains). If you’re visiting in winter, bundle up—the potbelly stove helps, but the bar can be drafty. Finally, take time to look at the walls. Every photo, clipping, and artifact tells a story, from the gangster past to the McSorley’s Old Ale House 1970 court case.
Pairing Your Visit with Other NYC Experiences
McSorley’s Old Ale House is in the heart of the East Village, making it easy to combine with other NYC attractions. After your visit, head to Union Square for shopping or people-watching. The Strand Bookstore, a short walk away, is a book lover’s paradise with rare finds. If you’re into music, check out a show at Webster Hall, a historic venue nearby. For a taste of NYC’s nightlife, the East Village is packed with bars and restaurants, from dive bars to trendy spots.
If you’re staying nearby, consider a hotel in Greenwich Village or Lower Manhattan. The Washington Square Hotel, with its cozy rooms and proximity to McSorley’s, is a great choice. It’s got a 9.0/10 rating on Expedia and offers breakfast, perfect for starting your day before hitting the bar.
For theater fans, Broadway is a short subway ride away, with shows like Hamilton or MJ the Musical offering a perfect evening out. Whether you’re captivated by the revolutionary storytelling of Hamilton, which blends history with contemporary music and powerful performances, or drawn to the dynamic energy of MJ the Musical, celebrating the life and legacy of the King of Pop, there’s something for every taste. These shows offer a perfect evening out, combining top-tier acting, stunning choreography, and unforgettable music in iconic venues that capture the magic of New York City’s theater scene. Plus, the nearby area is filled with great dining options and lively nightlife, so you can make the entire night an experience to remember.
McSorley’s and Other Historic Pubs in NYC
McSorley’s Old Ale House isn’t the only historic pub in New York City. Pair your visit with stops at other historic pubs in New York City for a full taste of NYC’s bar scene. The White Horse Tavern in Greenwich Village, open since 1880, is another legend, known for its literary connections to Dylan Thomas. Pete’s Tavern, also in the East Village, claims to be NYC’s oldest continuously operating bar, dating to 1864. Fraunces Tavern in Lower Manhattan, open since 1762, predates even McSorley’s and hosted George Washington.
Each pub has its own vibe, but McSorley’s NYC stands out for its raw authenticity. While Pete’s Tavern offers a more polished setting, McSorley’s keeps things gritty with its sawdust and cash-only rules. Fraunces Tavern leans into its Revolutionary War history, while McSorley’s Old Ale House feels like a living snapshot of the 19th century. Visiting these bars together gives you a sense of how NYC’s drinking culture has evolved.
Staying Near McSorley’s: Hotel Options
If you’re planning to visit McSorley’s Old Ale House, staying nearby makes your trip easier. The East Village and surrounding areas like Greenwich Village and Lower Manhattan have great hotels. The PUBLIC, an Ian Schrager hotel, is a stylish option with an 8.4/10 rating on Expedia, located just a short walk from McSorley’s. Its modern design and affordable rates (around $268/night) make it a solid choice.
Your McSorley’s Adventure Awaits
McSorley’s Old Ale House is a must-visit for anyone wanting to experience New York City’s rich history. From its 1854 opening to its gangster past and the McSorley’s Old Ale House 1970 court case, this bar tells the story of NYC through its ale-soaked floors and memorabilia-covered walls. Whether you’re sipping a light ale, chatting with regulars, or soaking in the gritty charm, McSorley’s NYC offers a unique connection to the city’s past. Pair your visit with a one day guided sightseeing tour to see more of Manhattan’s hidden gems, or catch a Broadway theater show like Hamilton for a perfect NYC evening. For more visitor information, head to VisitNYC.com to plan your trip with tips and tickets.
