Home / Blog / A Tour of NYC’s Historic Theaters: Broadway Beyond the Big Shows

A large theater seen during a New York City travel guide

A Tour of NYC’s Historic Theaters: Broadway Beyond the Big Shows

New York City is synonymous with Broadway, but its historic theaters go beyond the big productions. The city boasts a range of beautiful venues that showcase Off-Broadway plays, experimental performances, and culturally significant productions. These theaters not only highlight the city’s rich theatrical history but also provide a closer, more intimate connection to the art of storytelling.

The Public Theater: A Cradle of Creativity

Located in the East Village, The Public Theater has been a cornerstone of NYC’s theatrical innovation since 1967.

  • Significant Productions:This venue is best known for being the birthplace of legendary productions like Hamilton and A Chorus Line. The Public Theater continues to host groundbreaking new works and experimental plays.
  • Architecture and Ambiance:Housed in the historic Astor Library building, the theater combines 19th-century architectural charm with modern performance spaces.
  • Why Visit:The Public’s mission to bring theater to everyone means ticket prices are often more accessible. Don’t miss its Shakespeare in the Park productions at the Delacorte Theater in Central Park during the summer.
Cherry lane theatre seen during a small group tour in New York City

Cherry Lane Theatre

Cherry Lane Theatre: A West Village Gem

Cherry Lane Theatre, tucked into the heart of the West Village, is NYC’s oldest continuously operating Off-Broadway theater.

  • Historical Significance:Established in 1924, it has nurtured the work of legendary playwrights such as Samuel Beckett and Tennessee Williams.
  • Intimate Performances:The small size of the theater creates an intimate viewing experience, perfect for thought-provoking plays and experimental works.
  • Local Connection:Many productions at Cherry Lane Theatre reflect the artistic spirit of Greenwich Village, blending classic storytelling with contemporary issues.

Apollo Theater: A Cultural Icon

The Apollo Theater in Harlem is a legendary venue renowned for its influence on African-American culture and music.

  • Musical Roots:While primarily known for music, including its famous Amateur Night, the Apollo has also hosted theatrical performances and spoken word events that celebrate African-American heritage.
  • Rich History:Opened in 1914, the Apollo has seen performances from icons like Billie Holiday and James Brown, making it a living museum of American cultural history.
  • What to Look For:Beyond regular shows, the Apollo offers educational programs and historical tours, perfect for those interested in its storied past.
Cars parked on a road in front of a theater during a city trip to New York

Apollo Theater

New Victory Theater: Perfect for Families

Located in the heart of Times Square, the New Victory Theater is dedicated to family-friendly performances.

  • Educational Focus:The theater emphasizes engaging young audiences, offering productions from around the world that are tailored for children and families.
  • Historic Building:Opened in 1900 as a vaudeville house, the New Victory Theater has retained its historic charm while adapting to modern needs.
  • Why It Stands Out:It’s a great option for families visiting NYC, providing a cultural experience that is both entertaining and enriching for kids.

St. George Theatre: Staten Island’s Crown Jewel

St. George Theatre in Staten Island offers an exquisite blend of history and entertainment just a short ferry ride away from Manhattan.

  • Architectural Beauty:Built in 1929, the theater features Spanish and Italian Baroque elements, creating a visually stunning environment.
  • Diverse Performances:From classic plays to concerts and comedy shows, St. George Theatre offers a variety of entertainment options.
  • Family-Friendly Atmosphere:Its programming often includes family-oriented events, making it a versatile destination for visitors of all ages.
Interested in the history of Broadway?Here’s a tour that will keep you entertained in NYC!

The Players Theatre: A Greenwich Village Staple

Nestled in Greenwich Village, The Players Theatre has been a hub for Off-Broadway productions and experimental theater since 1953.

  • Versatile Space:The theater features multiple performance areas, making it a popular choice for a wide range of productions, from musicals to spoken word events.
  • Community Engagement:The Players Theatre often collaborates with local artists and companies, fostering a strong sense of community.
  • Why It’s Unique:Its intimate setting ensures a close connection between performers and the audience, offering a more personal theater experience.
A large building in a street seen during a one-day sightseeing tour

Brooklyn Academy of Music

Brooklyn Academy of Music (BAM): A Hub for Modern Art

While primarily known for avant-garde performances, BAM in Brooklyn has a rich history dating back to 1861.

  • Innovative Productions:BAM’s programming often includes groundbreaking theatrical performances, dance, and multimedia works.
  • Historic Spaces:The Howard Gilman Opera House, part of BAM’s complex, is a beautiful venue that combines historic architecture with state-of-the-art technology.
  • Events and Programs:Beyond theater, BAM hosts film screenings, talks, and workshops, making it a cultural hub in NYC.

Astor Place Theatre: Home of the Blue Man Group

Located in NoHo, Astor Place Theatre is best known for being the permanent home of the Blue Man Group’s quirky performances.

  • Historic Venue:The theater, built in 1831, was originally a single-family home before being converted into a performance space.
  • Unique Shows:Blue Man Group’s interactive and multimedia performances are a hallmark of this venue, offering a one-of-a-kind experience for visitors.
  • Accessibility:Its location in Manhattan makes it easily accessible for tourists and locals alike.

Theatre 80 St. Marks: A Piece of Off-Broadway History

This small yet historic theater in the East Village has been a favorite among Off-Broadway enthusiasts since the 1960s.

  • Historical Productions:Theatre 80 has hosted performances from some of the most prominent names in American theater and continues to feature independent and innovative works.
  • Museum of the American Gangster:Located in the same building, this museum adds an extra layer of intrigue to your visit, focusing on NYC’s prohibition-era history.
  • Neighborhood Vibe:Its East Village location places it within walking distance of some of the city’s best bars and restaurants.

Preserving NYC’s Theatrical Legacy

New York City’s historic theaters offer much more than just entertainment; they are cultural landmarks that reflect the city’s diverse history and vibrant artistic spirit. Whether you’re drawn to the grandeur of venues like the Apollo Theater or the intimate charm of Cherry Lane Theatre, there’s something special about each of these spaces. With Visit NYC, you can discover the best tourist things to do in NYC, how to get Hamilton tickets, and get one-day tours of New York.