New York City is a dream destination for food lovers. From iconic bagels to pizza slices that define a generation, the city is a melting pot of flavors. But let’s be honest—nobody wants to fall into the overpriced tourist traps that charge double for half the taste. If you’re looking for NYC’s Best Food Tour, the Upper West Side Food Tour takes you to real-deal, mouthwatering eats without the crowds. Buckle up for an NYC food tour for foodies that you won’t forget.
Start with a New York Classic: Bagels at Broad Nosh
Every great food tour should begin with a solid breakfast, and nothing screams New York quite like a fresh bagel. We kick off our food tour itinerary in NYC at Broad Nosh Bagels on 86th Street. These bagels are perfectly boiled and baked, delivering the signature chewiness that makes NYC bagels legendary. Go for the classic cream cheese or try something bold like lox or scallion spread. Either way, you’re in for a treat.
To truly appreciate the artistry behind NYC bagels, it’s essential to understand what makes them unique. The secret lies in the water—New York City’s mineral-rich water is believed to enhance the texture of the dough. Broad Nosh has perfected this technique, ensuring that every bite delivers the perfect blend of crisp crust and chewy interior.
A Slice of Heaven: Mimi’s Pizza
Pizza in NYC isn’t just food—it’s a way of life. But finding the perfect slice without standing in a line full of tourists can be tricky. Enter Mimi’s Pizza, a neighborhood gem on Broadway that serves up pies crafted with love and patience. The dough ferments for 72 hours before hitting the oven, giving it that perfect balance of crisp and chew. Whether you go for a classic cheese slice or something adventurous, this stop is a must on your NYC food tour recommendations list.
NYC pizza has a long and storied history. It all started with Lombardi’s in 1905, the city’s first pizzeria. Since then, every borough has developed its own pizza identity, from the thin, foldable slices of Manhattan to the deep-dish Sicilian-style pizzas of Brooklyn. Mimi’s sticks to the traditional New York slice—thin, cheesy, and packed with flavor.
Sweet Bites at Zabar’s: A Jewish Deli Staple
Next up, we visit Zabar’s, an iconic Jewish market that’s been feeding New Yorkers for nearly a century. While the market itself is packed with gourmet goods, the real highlight here is their homemade rugelach. These little pastries, filled with chocolate or cinnamon, are the perfect mid-tour snack. If you love coffee, be sure to grab a cup—it’s some of the best in town.
Zabar’s is more than just a bakery; it’s a New York institution. Opened in 1934, this family-run business has remained a staple for locals who appreciate high-quality smoked fish, gourmet cheeses, and freshly baked goods. Walking into Zabar’s is like stepping back in time, where old-school customer service meets a love for fine foods.
Street Food Like a Local: Gray’s Papaya
New Yorkers take their hot dogs seriously, and there’s no better place to experience this staple than Gray’s Papaya. Open for over 50 years, this no-frills spot serves 100% beef hot dogs that are juicy, flavorful, and incredibly affordable. Pair your dog with their famous tropical fruit juice, and you’ve got the ultimate NYC street food experience.
The appeal of Gray’s Papaya isn’t just in its food—it’s in its history. The shop has been featured in countless movies and TV shows, cementing its place in New York culture. The combination of affordability and flavor makes it a go-to spot for everyone from taxi drivers to celebrities.
Hidden Gems and Historic Sights
Between bites, we take a moment to explore some Upper West Side landmarks. The Belnord Apartments, a stunning residential complex, is famous for being the primary filming location of Only Murders in the Building. We also stop by the legendary Beacon Theatre, which has hosted the likes of Bob Dylan and the Rolling Stones. If you’re into street art, you’ll love Banksy’s “Hammer Boy” mural, a small but iconic piece of NYC culture.
Decadent Desserts: Magnolia Bakery
No gourmet food tour in NYC is complete without something sweet. We end our journey at Magnolia Bakery, known for their heavenly banana pudding and classic cupcakes. The creamy layers of vanilla pudding, fresh bananas, and Nilla wafers create a dessert that’s both nostalgic and indulgent. If you’re more of a cupcake fan, their signature buttercream frosting will not disappoint.
Magnolia Bakery became a global sensation after appearing in Sex and the City, but it remains a local favorite. Despite the crowds, the quality of their baked goods has never wavered, making it a worthy stop on our food tour.
Beyond the Tour: Other Must-Try Upper West Side Restaurants
If you’ve got room for more, the Upper West Side is packed with incredible dining spots beyond this tour. Here are a few you should check out:
- Jacob’s Pickles – A Southern comfort food haven known for fried chicken, biscuits, and house-made pickles.
- RedFarm – A modern Chinese restaurant offering creative dim sum, including their famous Pac-Man dumplings.
- Barney Greengrass – A legendary Jewish deli serving some of the best smoked fish and egg platters in town.
- Flor de Mayo – A fusion spot blending Peruvian, Chinese, and Spanish flavors in an unexpected but delicious way.
Why This is One of the Best Food Tours in New York
What makes this tour stand out? It’s all about authenticity. You won’t find overpriced, tourist-packed restaurants here—just incredible food at local-loved spots. This tour is a love letter to NYC’s diverse food culture, showcasing the best bites from long-standing institutions and hidden neighborhood gems. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a seasoned New Yorker, this food lover’s guide to NYC is guaranteed to satisfy your taste buds.
Experience More with VisitNYC.com
New York City is packed with unforgettable experiences, and we’re here to help you discover them. Whether you’re looking for a sightseeing tour in New York, a Broadway show, or the best tourist things to do in NYC, we’ve got you covered. Want to make a day of it? Pair this Manhattan day trip with a visit to Central Park, a museum tour, or even a sunset cruise on the Hudson.
Find tickets for a variety of events, attractions, and activities across New York. Your next adventure starts here!
